I’ve been busy reorganizing some of our vintage Halloween collectibles – which we all know is just top-secret code for …
I’ve been busy reorganizing some of our vintage Halloween collectibles – which we all know is just top-secret code for …
Finding a mid-century plastic pumpkin pail – whether it’s an Empire original from the 1960s or a rare, dimpled General …
There is a thrill that comes with the arrival of October. For me, the season’s magic lies in chasing that …
Welcome to Making Make Believe, your year-round home for vintage haunts, handmade magic, and a modicum of mischief. Guided by a love for cozy nostalgia, vintage memorabilia, and eerie elegance, I design unique Halloween decor and costume pieces right from my curiosity-filled studio. I'm so glad you're here to celebrate the spooky season with me. Whether you want to spark your own creative mischief or explore the exclusive designs waiting inside The Haunted Library, you've found your people.
Marsha Smith with Making Make Believe is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
A carefully curated collection of a few of our favorite themes.
You can make today!
Last-minute DIYs for when you need it now.
© 2026 Making Make Believe, LLC
Browse popular categories
Join Our Mailing List
Browse popular categories
